How Scientists Checked Whether Bennu’s Ammonia and Amino Acids Came From Earth

NASA’s OSIRIS-REx mission brought rock and dust from the asteroid Bennu back to Earth. When researchers found ammonia and amino acids, they had to ask whether the material came from the asteroid, the spacecraft or the lab. Their results strongly support an origin beyond Earth for much of what they measured, but one amino-acid result still has a plausible lab explanation.

Helpful resources

Loading matched recommendations...

A clean sample still needs a comparison

The team used controlled handling to limit what could get into the sample. The study’s Methods, PDF page 8, describes sealing one portion under nitrogen gas. NASA’s October 2023 curation update records a different precaution: the team removed and saved 14 small disks called witness plates, which had monitored conditions inside the spacecraft. A witness plate is a record of possible exposure, not a certificate that the sample stayed clean.

The lab had another comparison: a procedural blank, which goes through the preparation and testing without any asteroid material. If a compound appears in the blank, the asteroid isn’t the only possible source. Figure 3 of the paper puts an amino-acid blank alongside the Bennu results. That comparison would matter for valine.

What the nitrogen measurement says about ammonia

The researchers measured nitrogen in a liquid that contained ammonia, amino acids and other substances pulled from the material with hot water. The liquid was rich in nitrogen-15, a heavier form of nitrogen. Its reading was +180 ± 47 parts per thousand relative to the reference used for nitrogen isotope measurements. That’s a measure of the balance between forms of nitrogen, not the amount of ammonia in the liquid.

Helpful resources

Loading matched recommendations...

The spacecraft’s hydrazine propellant had a much smaller enrichment, +4.7 parts per thousand. The authors say that mismatch argues against fuel as the source of the ammonia. The extract’s reading also fell outside the range the paper gives for Earth’s organic matter. As the Results and Discussion explain, on PDF pages 2 and 5, the higher value came from the mixture. It wasn’t an isotope measurement of isolated ammonia or of each individual amino acid.

Why some amino acids made a stronger case than others

Some amino acids come in mirror-image forms, like a left and right hand. Within measurement uncertainty, the researchers found approximately equal amounts of both forms of alanine and aspartic acid. Along with the broader mix, which included molecules rare or absent in biology, that supported an origin beyond Earth. See Figure 3 and its surrounding discussion, PDF pages 4–5.

Valine was the exception worth slowing down for. After one portion of the extract was treated with acid, it showed an excess of the left-handed form. The blank also showed elevated left-handed valine. The authors left laboratory contamination open as an explanation for the excess and said a separate isotope measurement of valine could help clarify its origin.

The overall evidence points to chemistry from beyond Earth. The finding doesn’t tell us where every molecule came from, and organic molecules aren’t proof of life. For an example of that distinction, NASA explains why Europa Clipper is a habitability mission, not a life-detection mission.

Helpful resources

Loading matched recommendations...


Discover more from Simply Sound Advice

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Share your love

Share your thoughts! Leave a comment...

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.