Blindsight: A Patient Got 29 of 30 Right on Lines He Said He Couldn’t See

In a 1974 study, a patient known as D.B. correctly told horizontal from vertical lines 29 times out of 30 in one test, even though he said he couldn’t see the lines. That mismatch is the heart of blindsight: visual information can guide a person’s answer in part of the visual field where they don’t report seeing the thing they’re answering about.

What D.B. was asked to do

After surgery near the back of his brain, D.B. lost vision in much of the left side of the space he could normally see while looking straight ahead. He could still see in other parts of his visual field. The researchers used that difference to explain the test: they first showed him what the two possible images looked like on his seeing side. Then he kept his eyes on a marker while they projected one image at a time into the area where he said he couldn’t see it.

In Experiment 3, on page 715 of the paper, he had to give one of two answers out loud: horizontal or vertical, diagonal or vertical, or X or O, depending on the test. Each set had 30 trials, with 15 of each option shown in random order. He didn’t learn how he’d done until the series was over.

What 29 out of 30 actually means

A guess was required on every trial. That instruction didn’t make the guesses random. With two choices and no usable information about the image, you’d expect about 15 right out of 30. In one test, D.B. got 29 right when the researchers used larger lines and displayed each for 62.5 milliseconds, about one-sixteenth of a second. With the smallest lines at that same exposure time, he got 19 right. Both results are in the Experiment 3 results on page 717. The size of the pattern mattered; 29 out of 30 wasn’t his score across all the tests.

What his answers couldn’t tell the researchers

The team had two records to compare: what D.B. got right and what he said the experience was like. He usually reported seeing nothing. When asked more about it, he sometimes described a vague sense of which way a line pointed or which shape appeared. That detail, in the discussion on page 721, is why “he said he couldn’t see the lines” is more accurate than “he experienced nothing at all.”

The paper considers more than one explanation for how visual information reached the parts of his brain that could use it. This test didn’t choose between them or settle what makes an experience conscious. What it did show is already strange enough: asking D.B. whether he saw a line and asking him which way it ran gave the researchers two different kinds of evidence. If they’d stopped at the first question, they would have missed what he could do.


Discover more from Simply Sound Advice

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Share your love

Share your thoughts! Leave a comment...

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.