How to Compare Two Homeowners Insurance Quotes Before Choosing the Cheaper One

Put both quotes side by side and circle anything that’s different or missing before you compare the annual premiums. If the cheaper quote doesn’t say how it would value roof damage, write “not shown” and ask for the wording. A blank doesn’t tell you whether something is covered, excluded, or handled differently.

Start with the same house and the same dates

Check that both quotes use the same address, occupancy, home and roof details, and coverage start date. Check the end date too. If one quote is for a different term, ask for both to be priced for the same 12 months rather than comparing a monthly payment with an annual premium. If the roof age or another property detail is wrong, get that corrected before comparing. The NAIC’s homeowners shopping guide explains how property details and coverage choices affect the price.

Match the coverage first

Use these rows in a simple side-by-side list. Mark each one same, different, or not shown.

CompareWhat to write down for each quote
LimitsDwelling (the home itself), other structures, belongings, loss of use, and personal liability. Note any lower limit for a specific item or kind of loss. Matching the dwelling limit doesn’t mean all the rest match.
Exclusions and endorsementsCheck the causes of loss you care about, such as wind or hail. Ask for the relevant policy wording and any endorsements, which can add or restrict coverage. Note what’s included at the quoted price and what’s only offered separately.
How a covered loss is valuedCheck the home, roof, and belongings separately. Don’t assume a replacement-cost entry for the dwelling answers the roof question.
DeductiblesNote the general deductible and any separate deductible for a specific cause of damage. For a percentage deductible, record the percentage, what it’s multiplied by, and which losses it applies to.

The NAIC’s comparison worksheet helps you line up limits, coverage, and deductibles. For loss settlement, the NAIC explains the difference: replacement cost uses the cost of repair or replacement with materials of similar kind and quality, while actual cash value accounts for depreciation. Neither label tells you by itself what a particular claim would pay. Check the limits, deductible, and conditions in the applicable wording.

A percentage deductible may use the home’s insured value as its base, as the NAIC’s shopping guide notes. Ask which dollar figure the quote actually uses. Don’t multiply the percentage by the repair bill or your purchase price just because those numbers are handy.

A $240 difference that doesn’t settle the question

Fictional example, not market prices or a claim estimate. Both quotes use the same home details and 12-month term. Both show a $350,000 dwelling limit. Here’s what the quote papers show for wind or hail:

Quote AQuote B
Annual premium$1,560$1,800
Wind or hail deductible2% of the $350,000 dwelling limit$2,500 flat
How covered wind or hail damage to the roof is valuedNot shownReplacement cost stated, subject to policy terms

Quote A is $240 less per year, but its quoted wind or hail deductible is $7,000 ($350,000 × 0.02), which is $4,500 higher than Quote B’s. That’s the deductible difference, not a prediction of what you’d pay on a specific claim. Quote A also leaves the roof settlement terms unanswered. Ask what happens to the annual premium if Quote A is reissued with the same wind or hail deductible and roof settlement terms as Quote B. If those terms aren’t available, compare the differences openly rather than treating the quotes as interchangeable.

Questions to send in writing

  • Can you confirm the home details, effective and end dates, and limits you used? Please correct any mismatches and send a revised quote.
  • What terms apply to wind or hail damage to the roof? Please send the relevant policy wording and endorsements, including any exclusions, separate limits, or settlement conditions.
  • What triggers each deductible? If it’s a percentage, what specific dollar amount is the base, and what deductible does that produce on this quote?
  • Can you match the other quote’s limits, deductibles, and loss-settlement terms? If not, please list what can’t be matched. What is the annual premium on the revised quote, and are any charges, discounts, or separate policies outside that figure?

Once the terms are confirmed, compare the annual premiums again. If a difference can’t be matched, decide whether you’re comfortable with that specific trade-off. If a term is still missing, keep it marked unknown. The cheapest number on the page doesn’t answer a question the quote leaves open.

If you’re buying the home, you can put the confirmed premium alongside taxes and your other housing costs in the Mortgage Affordability Calculator. Use it after comparing the quotes, not to judge what a policy covers.


Discover more from Simply Sound Advice

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Share your love

Share your thoughts! Leave a comment...

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.