Archaeologists studying the ancient Indus civilization found stone weights that fit a shared pattern even though the stones didn’t all weigh the same. One row in archaeologist J. Mark Kenoyer’s comparison table shows how that works: three groups of weights fall near 13.7 grams, but each group has a different average.
Loading matched recommendations...
Read one row before you read the whole table
Harappa and Mohenjo-daro, both in present-day Pakistan, were cities of the Indus civilization. In “Harappan stone weights,” page 116, Kenoyer describes a series that mostly doubles in its early steps: 1, 2, 4, 8, 16, 32 and 64. Those numbers tell you how each category relates to a base weight. The stones in category 16 weren’t meant to weigh 16 grams; they belong to a group with about 16 times the base mass. And the series has exceptions, so doubling doesn’t explain every weight.
Here is that category on its own, from Table 9.3, printed page 115, row F:
Loading matched recommendations...
| Published sample | Average mass | Weights in the sample |
|---|---|---|
| Harappa Archaeological Research Project (HARP) | 13.86 g | 10 |
| Vats | 13.67 g | 28 |
| Mackay, Mohenjo-daro | 13.73 g | 91 |
The smallest and largest of those averages are just 0.19 grams apart. That tells you how closely the three groups line up in this category. It doesn’t tell you that every stone was within 0.19 grams of every other one. To check that, you’d need the individual measurements, which aren’t in this row. The sample counts also matter: 13.86 grams summarizes 10 stones, while 13.73 grams summarizes 91.
Why an average can’t tell you who set the rules
A shared pattern and a single authority are two different claims. To see why, imagine two groups using the same set of categories. A stone with a chipped corner could weigh less than it did when it was made, even if its maker aimed for the same weight as everyone else. Kenoyer calls for checking wear and damage, on page 117, before drawing firmer conclusions about regional variation. That’s a reason to check the objects, not a reason to assume all the differences are damage.
On that same page, Kenoyer notes that weights found at Harappa were concentrated near gateways and craft areas. He suggests they might have been used for taxation or the collection of dues, but leaves open who kept the standards in use. Finding a weight near a gate gives researchers a place to start; it doesn’t tell them what was weighed in a particular transaction or who collected anything.
That’s what makes the table worth reading. You can see a common way to measure quantity without assuming everyone made identical weights or that one office was in charge. Deciding what an object was worth is a separate question. Our guide to barter and the challenge of agreeing on value takes up that distinction without answering how the Harappans actually paid.
Loading matched recommendations...
Discover more from Simply Sound Advice
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
