In 1853, the scientist Michael Faraday tested a séance practice called table-turning: were people resting their hands on a table moving it without realizing it? His letter to the editor of The Times describes a pointer that could tell the difference: it swung one way if the table went first and the other way if the hands did.
Loading matched recommendations...
A moving table doesn’t tell you what started it
In table-turning, people rested their hands on a table and waited for it to move. In his longer account of the experiment, Faraday said participants felt the table was pulling their hands along. The table’s movement wasn’t the disputed part. What mattered was whether it led or followed.
Watching the whole table only gets you so far. By the time it’s visibly moving, the hands are moving too. Faraday needed a way to catch a small shift between them before it became a big one.
How the pointer told the difference
One version Faraday described in his letter used a light lever that could turn around a point fixed to the table. The lever’s short arm was attached to a piece of cardboard that could slide over the tabletop. The participants rested their hands on the cardboard, and the long arm served as the pointer. The turning point moved with the table; the short arm could move with the hands.
Loading matched recommendations...
Take the example Faraday gave: the participants wanted the table to move to the left.
- If the table went left first, the pointer would move left.
- If the hands slid the cardboard left while the table stayed put, the pointer would move right.
- If neither moved, the pointer would stay still.
That rightward swing is the part to notice. It doesn’t mean the person pushed right. The lever turns around its pivot, so when the hands move its short arm left, the pointer at the other end goes right. The apparatus could show the hands shifting even when the tabletop hadn’t moved at all. But the pointer tracked movement between the hands and the table, not their movement across the room. In his longer account, Faraday described adding a separate gauge on the floor to check the table itself when the two explanations were disputed.
What changed when people could see it
When the pointer was hidden or participants looked away, it wavered, although they believed they were pressing straight down. Faraday reported evidence of sideways pressure in the direction the participants wanted the table to go, even when the table itself stayed still.
When participants watched the pointer and could see the difference between straight-down and sideways pressure, Faraday reported that the table-turning stopped. People still wanted the table to move and kept trying. What changed was that they could now see what their hands were doing. Faraday took this as evidence that unrecognized muscle action accounted for the movement in his trials. His letter describes both conditions.
What it showed, and what it didn’t
Faraday’s pointer wasn’t a lie detector. It showed motion between the hands and the tabletop; it couldn’t tell what a person meant to do. A participant could sincerely believe they were pressing straight down and still push a little sideways. That distinction matters more than deciding whether to trust the people at the table.
The experiment gives a physical explanation for the table-turning Faraday investigated. It doesn’t settle every séance or ghost report. The useful takeaway is narrower: don’t just ask whether something moved. Ask what you’d need to see to tell which part moved first. For a modern parallel, the “Behind the Scenes” section of the guide to ghost-hunting shows explains why an instrument’s reading needs an explanation.
Loading matched recommendations...
Discover more from Simply Sound Advice
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

