The HMS Daedalus Sea Serpent: Why the Captain Rejected the Seal Explanation

On August 6, 1848, Captain M’Quhae of the British warship HMS Daedalus reported seeing what he took to be an enormous sea serpent. Naturalist Richard Owen suspected an elephant seal whose trail of disturbed water made it look much longer. M’Quhae’s reply, reprinted in The Examiner, shows exactly where they disagreed: did the long shape behind the head belong to the animal, or were the sailors looking at its wake?

Helpful resources

Loading matched recommendations...

The captain insisted the length was real

In his reply, published on November 25, 1848, M’Quhae stood by his description of a flat head and what he estimated was at least 60 feet of visible length. He said the sailors considered the length when the object came nearest to the ship, and only then called it a serpent. That was his answer to Owen’s suggestion that expecting a serpent had influenced their estimate. It tells us how the captain remembered reaching that conclusion. It doesn’t give us a way to check the estimate against a measured body. Read the captain’s account in “The Sea Serpent Again,” on printed page 764.

Movement mattered, too. M’Quhae said they hadn’t seen the length they could make out bend up and down or side to side to drive the animal through the water. But he rejected the leap from we didn’t see it move that way to the animal had a stiff body. Those aren’t the same claim. The first is about what the sailors could see; the second is about how the animal was built.

What Owen thought the sailors had seen

Owen’s explanation wasn’t that the sailors had imagined the whole thing. He read the shape of the head in the report and drawing as more consistent with a mammal, and proposed a large seal. In his account, the submerged parts that drove the animal forward would stir up a long trail of water. If the trail looked like a continuation of the animal, a seal could account for a much longer shape than the body itself. Owen’s argument is quoted in Richard A. Proctor’s Pleasant Ways in Science, in “The Sea-Serpent,” printed pages 218–220.

Helpful resources

Loading matched recommendations...

The captain disputed both pieces. The head he remembered was flat, not rounded in the way Owen described it. And he didn’t believe experienced sailors looking at close range had mistaken a wake for a solid body. That second objection is the more important one. If M’Quhae saw a continuous body, Owen’s wake doesn’t explain the length. If some of that shape was water, the estimate doesn’t rule out a shorter animal.

What the letters can actually tell us

The captain’s report to the Admiralty, excerpted in Proctor’s book on printed pages 214–215, places the encounter in the South Atlantic, west of southern Africa. But the most useful record for understanding the dispute is the captain’s own printed reply: it shows that the disagreement wasn’t just over what to call an unfamiliar animal. The men disagreed on what part of the sight counted as the animal in the first place.

A detailed witness account deserves more than a shrug. It also can’t settle a question it gives us no independent way to test. M’Quhae’s reply records what an eyewitness insisted he saw. Owen’s explanation shows how a known animal might produce a misleading outline. Without a specimen or another record that clearly separates the body from the water behind it, neither establishes what passed the Daedalus.

Explore more accounts and the evidence behind them in Paranormal & Unexplained.

Helpful resources

Loading matched recommendations...


Discover more from Simply Sound Advice

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Share your love

Share your thoughts! Leave a comment...

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.