Your mortgage payment went up, and a tax or insurance notice showed up around the same time. If you pay those bills through escrow, part of your mortgage payment goes into an account the company that collects your mortgage uses to pay them. Before you decide that company, called your mortgage servicer, made a mistake, figure out which number changed. An estimate for the next year, a bill for this year, and a payment someone already sent are three different things.
Loading matched recommendations...
If a notice says your property taxes are overdue or your homeowners insurance is about to lapse, contact the mortgage servicer and the tax office or insurer promptly. Ask the issuer what is unpaid and when the next action is due. Don’t wait for the annual statement to sort it out. The CFPB’s escrow problem guide explains what to do if your servicer missed an escrow payment.
Find the line that changed
Put two monthly mortgage statements side by side. Compare the amount collected for escrow first. If that didn’t change, check principal and interest, mortgage insurance, and any fees instead. The CFPB lists several reasons a mortgage payment can change, and they don’t all involve escrow.
If escrow changed, pull your latest annual escrow statement and the actual county tax bill or homeowners insurance renewal. The federal escrow rule separates the past year’s account history from the next year’s projection. The history can include assumed activity for the last two months, so check a suspected payment against the servicer’s transaction record and the issuer’s records.
Loading matched recommendations...
| Look at this | What it tells you | What to check next |
|---|---|---|
| Next year’s escrow projection | What the servicer expects to pay, and when | Does the estimate match the latest bill or renewal for the same period? |
| Tax bill or insurance renewal | What the issuer says it charged for a specific period | Is this the same parcel, policy, installment, or coverage period as the escrow line? |
| Servicer’s payment record and issuer’s payment history | What the servicer records as sent and what the issuer shows as received | Can you match the amount, date and recipient? If you paid directly, does your receipt show payment for that same charge? |
A copy of a bill doesn’t settle who was supposed to pay it. For the line you’re checking, ask the servicer whether it’s included in your escrow account, then ask the issuer how any payment was credited. A tax installment or insurance policy period is more useful than two dollar amounts that happen to look alike.
Work one difference at a time
Say the escrow projection lists $2,400 for a year of county taxes. The county’s bill for that same parcel and tax year says $2,640. That’s a $240 difference, or $20 a month if you spread just that difference over 12 months. It isn’t a prediction of your mortgage payment. An escrow shortage repayment or a separate insurance change can move the total by a different amount.
Start with one question: “Which county bill and tax year did you use for the $2,400?” If the servicer used an older bill, ask whether it can review the current one and when you should expect an answer. If the servicer says it paid the county, ask for the payment date, amount and any reference number, then ask the county where it posted. If the county shows your own payment too, ask it to confirm whether both payments went to the same installment before assuming you paid twice.
Get the answer in writing
You don’t need to explain the whole mortgage to get one line checked. Try this:
“My escrow statement dated May 10 projects $2,400 in county taxes. The county bill for the same property and tax year shows $2,640. Can you confirm the bill you used, whether any installment has already been paid from escrow, and send me the breakdown in writing?”
Save the bill, the escrow page, any payment receipt, and the servicer’s response. If the records still don’t line up, the CFPB explains when a written information request or notice of error may help. The immediate goal is simpler: know whether you’re looking at a different estimate, a different bill, or a payment that hasn’t been accounted for.
Loading matched recommendations...
Discover more from Simply Sound Advice
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
