How to Read the Arecibo Message and What an Alien Would Have to Guess

In 1974, the Arecibo radio telescope in Puerto Rico sent 1,679 bits, each a one or a zero, toward a distant star cluster. Those ones and zeros can be laid out as a picture, but getting a picture and knowing what it means are two different problems.

What Arecibo actually sent

The November 16 transmission marked the dedication of a telescope upgrade. Cornell’s account of the event says the narrow beam was aimed toward Messier 13, a cluster of stars roughly 25,000 light-years away, and the whole transmission lasted about three minutes. The telescope shifted the radio frequency to distinguish the two bit values. It didn’t beam a color picture into space; the colors you may see in illustrations are there to help readers tell the sections apart.

Turn the bits into a picture

Start with 1,679 = 23 × 73. Because 23 and 73 are both prime, the only rectangular layouts with more than one row and column are 73 rows of 23 or 23 rows of 73. That makes a grid a good thing to try. It doesn’t tell you how to fill it.

The binary listing and annotated illustration published by Carl Sagan and Frank Drake show the intended arrangement: 73 rows of 23. Fill each row from right to left before starting the next one below it. Treat each 1 as a filled square and each 0 as an empty one. It’s like turning a string of instructions into a sheet of pixel art. Make the rows 73 bits wide instead and the lines break at different places. Even with the right dimensions, you still have to choose where to start and which way to read.

Read three numbers before tackling the whole picture

Find the number groups at the top of Sagan and Drake’s annotated picture. The separate marks below the groups identify the column containing the ones place. Don’t count those marks as digits. Under the diagram’s convention, read the three rightmost groups from the right edge inward, and the digits in each group from top to bottom:

Three numbers in the Arecibo message
BitsReading them as binaryValue
001One in the ones place1
010One in the twos place2
011One in the twos place and one in the ones place3

Here the places are worth four, two, and one, instead of the hundreds, tens, and ones of ordinary decimal notation. Once you know what counts as a digit and what counts as a marker, you can check the numbers yourself. The trick an unfamiliar reader faces is working out that convention in the first place.

What the designers meant the shapes to say

The annotated picture and its accompanying explanation do more than show where the colored sections go. They tell us what the designers intended:

  • A group of numbers stands for the atomic numbers of hydrogen, carbon, nitrogen, oxygen, and phosphorus. An atomic number is the number of protons in an atom’s nucleus.
  • Nearby patterns describe chemical components of DNA, and a winding graphic represents DNA’s double helix.
  • A simplified human figure appears above a diagram of the solar system. The third planet is set apart from the line to mark Earth as the sender’s home.
  • The bottom shape represents the Arecibo telescope, the instrument that sent the message.

Nothing in the rectangle itself labels one pattern “DNA” or another “telescope.” Those are meanings we can check against the designers’ key, not things two prime factors prove.

Finding a pattern isn’t the same as understanding it

A receiver would first have to detect the radio signal and recover its sequence. Then comes the harder question: does a lone displaced square mean “we live here,” or is it just an odd bit in a drawing? The transmission shows that people on Earth could design and send a compact picture. It doesn’t show that anyone received or understood it.

That’s also why the 2022 Beacon in the Galaxy paper is a different thing. Its authors proposed an expanded message with an introduction to mathematical and physical concepts and a time-stamped location for the solar system. The paper describes a proposal for possible future transmission, not part of what Arecibo sent in 1974.

For the broader distinction between listening for signals and deliberately messaging extraterrestrial intelligence, see “Shooting the First Text: METI” in the guide to extraterrestrial life.


Discover more from Simply Sound Advice

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Share your love

Share your thoughts! Leave a comment...

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.